Great Debate #1: Realism vs. Fun - Choosing the Winner

[Alena Rybik]

Actually this way no winner can be declared.

I have to post for Knut because realism is important for me. If I don't vote for Knut I am basically saying "i don't care for realism". I also say "I don't care about fun" which is very against what I want to vote for. If I vote for TundraPuppy I am saying "I don't care about realism" which I would never want to be quoted on and "It's all about the fun" (which would perfectly fit on good ballanced realism) but can't be voted because its in the wrong context.

As I wrote in my OP, "we're determining the winner of the debate, NOT the winning concept. Pick the one who you think managed to present his arguments in the best and most argumentative way."

[Pratze]

Actually this way no winner can be declared.

I have to post for Knut because realism is important for me. If I don't vote for Knut I am basically saying "i don't care for realism". I also say "I don't care about fun" which is very against what I want to vote for. If I vote for TundraPuppy I am saying "I don't care about realism" which I would never want to be quoted on and "It's all about the fun" (which would perfectly fit on good ballanced realism) but can't be voted because its in the wrong context.

As I wrote in my OP, "we're determining the winner of the debate, NOT the winning concept. Pick the one who you think managed to present his arguments in the best and most argumentative way."

yes I forgot about that when posting. I voted for Knut because I think he did a better job of backing his arguments. But I have to say TundraPuppy did an awsome job as well. It was pretty close!

[polihunter]

Mi voto siempre para el realismo, pero también puede ir acompañado de diversión. Caza realismo con diversión, para eso es un juego.

[BCKidd]

Knut really hit it on the head- my vote is for him. His arguments were concise and well thought out. Peace.

BCKidd.

[RayJRabbit]

How about this. Instead of changing the game, add a camo set that is legendary scent, sight and sound reduction vs all species for those who want the "fun" aspect. Those who want to stay true to real hunting have no need to buy it.

[Dukkers]

Been busy in the real world and gone for a while. But God Mode Gear? Have to be careful with the comps then otherwise ok. Both sides did well but I think Knut edged out Tundra Puppy. Now to get a quick hunt in before I have to start building another website for a restaurant.

[jpm1]

i didn't follow that debate as i didn't understand the concept of taking 2 guys (that i respect) and let them speak for thousands . i don't want to be OT but i think that as a game TH can't be nor too realistic nor too arcade . so , i won't vote , i just love the game as it is right now

[Urgia]

I smell difficulty levels implementation.

Time to give hardcore players their due.

[Dillion1111]

I voted for realism,

The game is too phony when you can shoot whole herds of animals with no effort.

[jpm1]

if you want realism that means 1 or 2 animals per hunting session . the game is nice like it is right now