phil1 wrote:DHRifleman wrote:Ravenousfox wrote:"you probably noticed that it’s slightly more powerful than other two Recurve Bows. Based on this, we were contemplating not allowing it for the same competitions, but instead creating a separate category for it."
Really good decision, you should also change the other bow comps too, have the Recurve/Longbow/Cable-backed bow/Compound bows all separate, because allowing the Longbow to be with Compound bows you know everyone is just going to use the Compound bows over using the Longbow. Thus making the Longbow left out and unfair to the few people that use the Longbow competing with Compound bow users (you have a real disadvantage in those comps.)
If you have 1337 kills with the longbow at 100% kill rate, and I have less kills with any of my compounds and none are at 100% kill rate, how is that a disadvantage? You are obviously better with the long bow than I am with the compounds.
All bows have a 100% kill rate, if you can be bothered hanging around until the animal dies. If you hit an animal with any bow - it will die from the shot eventually, no matter where you hit it. Hit rate is a different matter, as is instant kill rate.
Actually I think all weapons have a 100% kill rate if you have enough time in the hunt. I don't think there is code that says certain projectiles will allow the animal to stop bleeding. Location of the hit along with the actual projectile used, and the distance at which the animal was struck determines the bleed rate. Arrows have a low initial damage, and higher bleed rate VS bullets having high initial damage, and a slower bleed rate. It is possible that there isn't enough time in a hunting day for some animals to expire based on a very slow bleed rate due to distance, projectile and location of the hit, but I do believe they never stop bleeding health.
So in order to have the amount of kills RF has (over 1500 now) with 100% kill rate, he must have hit every animal only once, and found every animal. A bad shot with a bow can still have the animal last a long time and travel great distances which greatly increases the chance of either time running out, or just not finding the animal due to some issues with the tracking system. Things like tracks buried under rocks and the general landscape can make tracking the animal quite difficult if not close to impossible some times.
So I still believe RF is better with the longbow, than many are with any of the compounds, myself included.